« Responding to Democracy | Main | Gregg Easterbrook is Out of Touch »

May 02, 2005

Frist's Lament

Lost among Pat Robertson's quasi-endorsement of Rudy Giuliani for president and his insane comments on religious litmus tests for judges, Pat Robertson made another unexpected move last Sunday: He cut Bill Frist loose.

Bill is a wonderfully compassionate human being. He is humanitarian. He goes on medical missions. He's a delightful person. I just don't see him as a future president. I think he's said he didn't want to run for president. Maybe I'm putting words in his mouth.

Ouch. It'd be little wonder if the good Doctor began questioning why he was expending all this energy, capital, and poor press kowtowing to Robertson's agenda. But Frist, in his unfortunate way, was destined for this electoral purgatory. The Christian Right is, if nothing else, an authentic organization and they're going to push the candidates who excite them, not the one's who've been dutiful. That means Santorum, Owens, Allen, and even Giuliani can expect some troops, but the hapless majority leader is unlikely to find himself riding to victory atop some megachurch-based uprising. Now, it may be that Frist simply felt that he needed to neutralize the far right's opposition to his candidacy, which he's surely done. But without a natural constituency to run with, lukewarm acceptance by theocrats isn't going to do him much good, and while his slavish attentiveness towards Bush's agenda might get him a pat on the head from conservatives, the truth is that no one falls in love with a follower.

May 2, 2005 in Election 2008 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c572d53ef00d83477be9169e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Frist's Lament:

Comments

I offered this insight to my Mom (she watched Robertson, I didn't - Pelosi's poor performance was sad enough) - I think Robertson's always felt like a certain sort of social exile in Southern High Society, which is clearly Frist's world (we both thought Robertson is a Yankee). That society, which is, of course, as old as...well, Scarlett O'Hara, makes very clear who fits in and who doesn't. It's probably somewhat refreshing to folks like Robertson that they can wield some power and bring down someone from that world; it is, after all, not so vastly different from the anti-intellectual, common-man approch the religious right uses against the University left. But it's far more fascinating to watch the intraparty fighting.

Posted by: weboy | May 2, 2005 5:35:01 PM

Interesting, but you forgot Sam Brownback on your list of hopefuls. Owens is done because, well, he's going to lose in 2006. Ditto Santorum, too.

Its not entirely clear to me which of the high profile right-wing preachers actually have a following at this point. My impression is that Pat Robertson is actually on the outside looking in, and that James Dobson and the guy who runs the Catholic league (Tony Perkins?) are the real players.

Posted by: Electoral Math | May 2, 2005 6:42:10 PM

I really don't know much about anything but I think the right's love affair with Catholics and the Pope will soon pass. They love their guns and death penalty too much.

Posted by: mpower1952 | May 2, 2005 8:01:11 PM

mpower:

if they get the control the seek, the fundies will cut the catholics loose and nail them but good. Al Mohler is still defending his less than polite statements about the office of the pope and the catholic church (I guessed it's OK for a fundie to slam catholocism and that's not intolerant to religion, but a non fundie/catholic asks not to be forced to live in accordance to fundie dogma and we're anti-religion).

Posted by: Ol Cranky | May 2, 2005 8:47:23 PM

I don't think Robertson is a Yankee. I haven't seen any proof of his Puritan or Pilgrim ancestors. True Yankees are just as exclusive as high Southern Society. We jsut value education more.

Posted by: Abby Vigneron | May 2, 2005 10:29:28 PM

What EM said. Frist wounding himself over and over again the past couple months, as well as the probable success of Bob Casey Jr. will do little more than clear the field for Allen. Everyone knows Owens has been unfaithful in his marriage, and he's not even floated as a possibility anymore. Giuliani is too liberal.

It's going to be Allen. It's going to be Allen. I am simply convinced of this. The goal of everyone who cares about these things needs to be laying a groundwork for his utter destruction as a candidate. We will not win unless he is an object of scorn and ridicule in a way even Dole and Bush Sr. weren't.

Did you know George Allen divorced his first wife because she wasn't pretty enough for politics? And that Wes Clark married his college sweetheart before shipping off for Vietnam? I think that's interesting, and I bet the American people would too.

Posted by: SamAm | May 2, 2005 11:42:11 PM

Cranky sounds as mystified as me about "Protestants" (of dogma) and their intolerance. The company has a long history of subverting religion overseas (the V.C. espionage/missionary link was not completely without merit) especially in Central America. Two guesses what part of the U.S. is awash with this (check out biography of Nelson Rockefeller).

Posted by: opit | May 3, 2005 12:32:17 AM

Isn't Rudy pro-choice and for gay rights? He doesn't mind a little adultery either. Something smells here. Rudy is not a good fit with the bible thumpers.

Posted by: marvyt | May 3, 2005 8:50:48 AM

Robertson likes the gay-friendly, divorced Guiliani? These guys have no standards.

Posted by: Poppy McCool | May 3, 2005 11:39:13 AM

More Allen;

less than a week after Pat Robertson's lunatic comments on "This Week" (comments some right-wing bloggers even called out) George Allen is going to Robertson's very own Regent University in VA Beach to give a commencement address. These two clowns deserve each other, but watch the oh-so principled folks at places like RedState ignore or explain away Allen's sucking up to the literal American Taliban.

Bastards all.

Posted by: SamAm | May 3, 2005 12:11:47 PM

"I think Robertson's always felt like a certain sort of social exile in Southern High Society, which is clearly Frist's world (we both thought Robertson is a Yankee)."

Robertson's dad was a U.S. Congressman and Senator from Virginia. I'm not at all sure what one has to do to fit in to southern high society, but speaking as a southerner I don't believe we're that persnickety.

Posted by: David | May 3, 2005 1:35:22 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.